AesthetIc dImensIon of ATLAS panels
BY GÜLAY YAŞAYANLAR
Cover of exhibition “Aby Warburg, Bilderatlas Mnemosyne: Reconstuction-Commentary-Revision Atlas, Curators: Roberto Ohrt and Axel Heil) © ZKM | Zentrum für Kunst und Medien, 2016, Karlsruhe. https://zkm.de/en/exhibition/2016/09/aby-warburg-mnemosyne-bilderatlas
Aby Warburg draws attention today with his privilege of perspective-interpretation that he developed through the problematic of image circulation and transformation in the transmission of history and culture, and which is nourished by the power of emotion. This conceptual orientation, which points to a radical break from the natural state of things and is shaped by acts of remembrance, this promise of producing new meaning, is influential in the field of cultural history and art. This perspective-interpretation, nourished by references to sociology, nature, religion, and mythology, and becoming comprehensive in terms of its trans-temporal and spatial aesthetic context, quickly subverts the stagnation of visual elements that appear with the presence of a temporary aura and reveals Warburg’s obsessive insight with a different image formulation. In this context, Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, which discusses the archaic structure of images and reveals the complex state of cultural memory through a natural selection method, gains importance and value almost as an emotional battlefield.
In Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, while treating images taken from art history as manifestations of visual culture, Warburg created a heterotopic space that sets in motion and energizes important iconic figures and sculptures frozen and solidified in memory. He arranges images side by side as signifiers of different language codes and opens new thinking spaces in the intermediate spaces consisting of meaning dualities. He can reproduce each panel of Bilderatlas Mnemosyne with a simple photomontage practice, transforming the blurred and alienated images of memory into living dynamicforms by stripping them of their petrified unrest. (1)
The insight that brings visual elements together by montaging them in Warburg is related to the existence and use of the image as a carrier of traditional cultural forms. It also means iconographic examination that seeks answers to unconsciously sourced questions that arise through the political,social, and cultural quality and transformation of the image. Therefore, Bilderatlas Mnemosyne reflects the questioning of what is actually visible in the relationality of photographs, letters, and things including special notes that are important from a conceptual and visual perspective. Warburg also shows in this multi-part arrangement that the power of diversifying and enriching the material will become much more effective with a meaning-making that develops in depth.
notes
1 Photomontage is a holistic image formed by bringing together two or more original images. It has become an important and preferred technique due to its potential to encourage viewers to think about the new relational situation it establishes between grouped images. Moreover, original or found photographs obtained by cutting and pasting with technical possibilities can be placed next to poetic dimensions and mysterious elements (such as texts and drawings and figures). Or, a new image can be obtained by changing an original photograph by cutting it. Photomontage, which holds the photographic image above everything else, has a striking visual dynamism. Due to its potential that directly leads to free association, it is adopted by artists and is frequently used with the idea of creating provocative relationships.
2 Susan Buck-Morss, Görmenin Diyalektiği / Walter Benjamin ve Pasajlar Projesi, Translation: Ferit Burak Aydar, Metis Yayınları, 1. Edition, İstanbul, January 2010, pg. 85.
Aby Warburg, Mnemosyne Atlas, 1929 (last version), Panel 39 (reconstruction by Roberto Ohrt and Axel Heil, 2020). Photo: Tobias Wootton. (Warburg Institute/Fluid, London)
Aby Warburg, Mnemosyne Atlas, 1929 (last version), Panel 41 (reconstruction by Roberto Ohrt and Axel Heil, 2020). Photo: Tobias Wootton. (Warburg Institute/Fluid, London)
The presence of both an attractive and threatening initiative in the thematic arrangement of images in Bilderatlas Mnemosyne reveals that each of the materials carries a historical clue value. Here, creative potential memory comes into play, and the seemingly harmonious state of images gains importance through the structuring of a comprehension problem through montage technique. In the sequential arrangement of images, their compromises that are essentially interrupted among themselves often invoke alienation rather than the fusion brought by montaging. Just as Benjamin stated: The montage technique, as a progressive form, interrupts the context in which it is placed and therefore resists illusion. And/but, the representational power of the images based onto panel surfaces actually increases its conceptual quality with the increase in the meaning gaps between the signifier and thesignified. (2) Thus, Warburg’s interest in archaic images expands the field of his own conceptual and genuine insights through a transformable montage technique. This is important in terms of showing the schizophrenic tones of Warburg’s unconscious that become fetishized with poetic dimensions and mysterious elements (such as texts and drawings and figures).
From this perspective, it is possible to say that each image is part of a wholeness that reveals the schizoid spirit of Bilderatlas Mnemosyne. For the construction of a new artistic meaning, there is no doubt that understanding well the thematic spirit of each image that supports the whole and that this arrangement has transformed into a cultural memory construction loaded with discoveries extending to the present day in Bilderatlas Mnemosyne. Warburg’s interest in the power of images has taken on an obsessive-passionate state here. Moreover, his sensitivity about the formal structure of the image-which opposes traditional values-is decisively expressed with the linguistic discourse of an insight hidden in all montage intervals of a libertarian psychology.
On the other hand, this discourse, combined with the photomontage effort that builds iconographic order and turns into a critical evaluation, reveals the essential dimensions of Warburg’s approach to artworks, namely the inner side of an alternative aesthetic perception. Here, Warburg also distinguishes the psychic quality that emerges in the layered structure between images appearing with the causality of image structuring and traces the expressions that remain hidden in memory images.
In a final look, Aby Warburg, as exemplified in Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, is like a passionate protagonist of a history of visual expression based on emotions and an attractive mental alienation game between subjective preferences along with image arrangements dedicated to remembrance. ♦
Gülay Yaşayanlar Copyright © 2025, All Rights Reserved
prof. gülay yaşayanlar Artist, art writer and curator. He has numerous publications on current issues, theoretical debates and prominent artist attitudes in the area of plastic arts. He lives and works in Izmir and London.
BILDERATLAS MNEMOSYNE (1925 – 1929)
Aby Warburg, Bilderatlas Mnemosyne – The Original, 2020 (installation view). Photo: Silke Briel. (Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin) Exhibition: Aby Warburg: Bilderatlas Mnemosyne – The Original, 4 September – 1 November 2020, Haus der Kulturen der Welt, Berlin.
Bkz. Aby Warburg, Bilderreihen ve Ausstellungen. Gesammelte Schriften-Studienausgabe, Cilt II.2, Editörler: Uwe Fleckner ve Isabella Woldt, eds. Akademie Verlag, 471 pages, Almanca, 2012.
NEW EXHIBITIONS
Exhibition, 1 October – 30 December 2024, Warburg Institute, Woburn Square, London. WC1H 0AB
This exhibition was organised to celebrate the completion of the Warburg Institute’s Warburg Renaissance project and the acquisition of new gallery spaces. Bringing together selected artists, writers and cultural historians, the exhibition is planned to present images and objects that reflect the history and development of the current collection. As is well known, the Warburg’s collections comprise a unique and uniquely assembled collection that links texts and images, social, scientific and magical elements of knowledge and images.
Exhibition, Curators: Roberto Ohrt and Axel Heil, 2 April – 22 June 2024, HKW Hause der Kulturen der Welt, in cooperation with the Warburg Institute London.
In his latest and unfinished project, Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, art and cultural historian Aby Warburg traces recurring visual themes and patterns over time, from antiquity, through the Renaissance and beyond, to contemporary culture. His approach is of great significance for today’s visual culture and the image world dominated by digital imagery. In this exhibition, HKW presents 63 panels of Bilderatlas in a manner faithful to Warburg’s original images.
Exhibition, Curators: Roberto Ohrt and Axel Heil, 31 August – 13 November 2016, ZKM Center for Art and Media in Karlsruhe.
On the occasion of Aby Warburg’s 150th birthday, the ZKM | Karlsruhe is exhibiting a complete reconstruction of his Bilderatlas in its original dimensions. In addition, 13 artist panels by contemporary artists round off the exhibition. These artists include Linda Fregni-Nagler, Sarah Lehnerer, Jochen Lempert, Jannis Marwitz, Paul McCarthy, Olaf Metzel and Matt Mullican, Albert Oehlen. This meeting clearly shows the interest that Bilderatlas attracts in art circles.
Exhibition, Curator: Georges Didi-Huberman, 7 May – 7 August 2011, ZKM Museum für Neue Kunst und Medien Karlsruhe. (Madrid – Karlsruhe- Hamburg)
According to exhibition curator Didi-Huberman, the idea behind the Atlas is not to collect masterpieces: The most important aspect of interest is the discovery of the sources on which the artists relied and which therefore make the various artistic procedures comprehensible. Thus, it is not Paul Klee’s watercolours that are on display here, but, inter alia, his modest herbarium and the graphic and theoretical ideas it inspired; it is not Josef Albers’ frames, but his photo album of images of pre-Columbian buildings.
PREPARED BY GÜLAY YAŞAYANLAR & MÜMTAZ SAĞLAM
ON ABY WARBURG VE BILDERATLAS MNEMOSYNE
BOOK PUBLICATIONS
E.H. Gombrich, Aby Warburg: An Entellectual Biography / Phaidon Press Ltd. 456 pages, English, Hardback, August 1997.
Uwe Fleckner, Der Blitz und die Schlange: Aby Warburgs Amerikanische Reise (Kulturgeschichte), Hatje Cantz Verlag, 150 pages, English, Hardback, November 2023.
Hans C. Hönes, Tanged Paths: A life of Aby Warburg, Reaktion Books, 288 pages, English, Hardcover, May 2024.
Aby Warburg 150, Work, Legacy, Promise Edited by: David Freedberg and Claudia Wedepohl, 464 pages, De Gruyter Publishing, English, 1st Edition, April 2024.
Blitzsymbol und Schlangentanz: Aby Warburg und die Pueblo-Kunst (Kulturgeschichte) Authors: Christine Chaves and Uwe Fleckner, Hatje Cantz Verlag, 400 pages, English, hardcover, March 2022.
Lara Bonneau, Lire l’œuvre d’Aby Warburg à la lumière de ses Fragments sur l’expression, 264 pages, French Edition, softcover, Şubat 2022.
Aby Warburg Miroirs de faille – À Rome avec Giordano Bruno et Édouard Manet, 1928-29, Edited: Maurizio Ghelardi, L’écarquille Published, French Edition, softcover, 224 pages, June 2011.
Aby Warburg: Essay Florentins, Edited: Eveline Pinto and Sibylle Muller, Hazan Published, French Edition, softcover, 368 pages, April 2015.
Aby Warburg: Bilderatlas Mnemosyne / Das Original, Edited by Haus der Kulturen der Welt and The Warburg Institute; Roberto Ohrt, Axel Heil, Publisher: Bundeskunnsthalle Bonn, Hardcover 2020.
Christopher D. Johnson, Memory, Metaphor, and Aby Warburg’s Atlas of Images, Ithaca: Cornell University Library and Cornell University Press, 2012.
Aby Warburg, Atlas Mnemosyne, Translator: Joaquin Chamore Mielke, Akal Ediciones SA, 192 pages, Spanish, Hardcover, Marc 2010.
Aby Warburg: Bilderatlas Mnemosyne / The Original, Edited by Haus der Kulturen der Welt and The Warburg Institute; Roberto Ohrt, Axel Heil, Publisher: Hatje Cantz, 184 pg. English, Hardcover 2020.
Gerhard Richter: Atlas, Editor: Helmut Friedel, Verlag der Buchhandlung Walther König/D.A.P., Second edition, Following the first of 1997. 862 pages. 2011. Köln/New York.
Atlas: How to Carry the World on One’s Back?, Editor: Georges Didi Huberman, 421 pages, English, 2011.
Aby Warburg: Mnemosyne Bilderatlas ZKM 2016, Editor: Georges Didi Huberman, Kartoffelverlag, Universal-futur-Bitch Press, 2016
ABY WARBURG
saglamart; dinamik bir anlayış ile hareket eden, kültür-sanat ortamındaki olay ve olgulara, sanatçı tavırlarına, yapıtlara ve yayınlara odaklanan bağımsız bir yayın etkinliğidir. Tüm hakları saklıdır. All rights reserved. Görüntü ve yazılar izinsiz kullanılamaz. Images and texts cannot be used without permission.