AN ANCIENT RITUAL
BY GÜLAY YAŞAYANLAR
Aby Warburg with a Pueblo Indian, 1896, USA. (https://warburg.sas.ac.uk/news/lightning-symbol-and-snake-dance-aby-warburg-and-pueblo-art-markk)
In addition to their symbolic value, the images frequently used by Aby Warburg in his lectures and conferences are also analysed in the context of a troubled future anxiety and unease that became visible with early modernism. In this context, it is interesting and important that Warburg, who is interested in the origins of social and cultural practices, investigates the Snake Dance ritual of the Pueblo Indians living in North America (1) Here, Warburg endeavours to reach the origins and unique qualities of a complex structure that both penetrates the layers of collective memory and penetrates the depths of the old, while at the same time preserving new things. As he wanders in the theatrical space of an archaic ritual and/or among the ruins of a disintegrated memory, he is also aware that he is having a contradictory psychic experience. (2)
a journey to the origins of the image
Revealing the origins of a traditional phenomenon that still persists in cross-cultural flow, this research focuses on the illusion created by an ironic magical power. This dangerous dance, also known as the prayer for rain, performed by the natives with lightning-like snakes, contains meanings beyond a vital meeting and a fight. Seeing and evaluating this situation as an ethnological legacy of a vital spirit that integrates itself with magic, Warburg empathises as a historical and social case (through this belief that continues today). He reaches the idea that this cultural dynamic (through the symbolic circulation and transformation of the snake figure) refers to later historical layers and, moreover, is a psycho-social factor determining the imagery in classical art. In this respect, the primordial character of archaic culture and its presence in the afterlife, and the fact that it constitutes the main axis of contemporary analyses, are related to the psychic glow contained in such wild and strange rituals.
Aby Warburg is a scientist and theorist who, in his search for spiritual freedom caught between two wars, associatively interrogates the correspondence of images in his own subjective world and realises an inner transformation each time. The experience of contemplation he observes in the lives of Pueblo Indians can turn into a mystical experience that brings him together with his own reality. In this respect, it is interesting that the mysticism of the Serpent Dance and the impulse it creates emerges years later at a time coinciding with his treatment process, enabling him to recover and reach the necessary motivation. This is precisely why the liberating experience and perception of reality observed by a psychology struggling with unlimited complexity in relation to what it senses in a primitive tribe, the beliefs and magical powers created by a ritual with cultural polysemy, is worth examining.
notlar
1 The Snake Dance is a dance that the natives have been doing for centuries for the spring rains. First, a geometric motif depicting the geography they live in is drawn on the dance field. Lightning bolts in the form of snakes are added between the plains and hills in the motif. After the drawing, the dancers start a hypnotic dance in a circle around this motif. Immediately afterwards, dozens of poisonous snakes are dropped on the motif in the centre of this circle. When the motif and the snakes mingle and become indistinguishable, the dancers one by one grab the snakes with their fangs, carry them out of the circle, and release them back into the desert to make their wishes. According to Warburg, this dance symbolises the internal and external demonic forces that humanity must overcome. On a symbolic level, primitive thought emphasises the enduring belief in the efficacy of primitive thought against the forces of nature (due to the pairing of the snake with lightning and rain), while at the same time drawing our attention to the transcendental ecstasy brought about by one-to-one contact with the poisonous animal.
2 The lecture on this subject titled ‘Images from the Pueblo Indian Reservation in North America’, which he gave at the clinic on 21 April 1923, consists of images and object images from 1895-96 documenting the life of the Indians.
An art historian in cowboy costume: Aby Warburg with one of the Hemiskatsina dancers at Oraibi, 1896, USA. (https://southwestcontemporary.com/new-book-on-aby-warburg/)
Aby Warburg, (Detail), Santa Fe, New Mexico, 1896 (https://www.warburg-haus.de/en/tagebuch/neuerscheinung-aby-warburg-bilder-aus-dem-gebiet-der-pueblo-indianer-in-nordamerika-vortraege-und-fotografien/)
warburg: wizard of the early modernist period
Indeed, there is no doubt that the energy contained in this dance also constitutes an experience of self-discovery that, in Warburg’s theoretical approach, triggers a critical spirit and mobilises a hopeful defensive instinct, referring to the presence of strong symbolic relations in the discussion of origin and provenance in classical works. We are talking here about the power of synthesis shaped by the expression of historical imagery on Warburg’s cultural evolutionary trajectory (which is a dialectical trajectory, blending archaic, mythic and religious emphases), including the early modern.
It is no coincidence that the analysis of the Snake Dance ritual undertaken by Warburg corresponds to the phase preceding the logic of mapping the visual memory of culture. The cultural connections between different time periods, the truth created by a surreal connection and the ongoing loss of reality through a social experience probably constitute for Warburg a foreseeable primordial threshold of historical time. It is important that this functions as a philosophical field of experience for a theorist. It is important that Warburg’s presentation of the Snake Dance as a primitive understanding of the Snake Dance of the Indians, Warburg’s extraction of the energy created by the metaphorical potential of this phenomenon from its context, and the discovery of a substructure that will decipher the archaic codes on this dance and give it a conceptual quality. Tracing the momentum of cultural construction, Warburg is of course aware of the strong connection of this ongoing empirical historical axis with cultural traditions and objects.
It is as if Warburg felt the first diagrams of the theoretical visual map, which he would later realise in Bilderatlas Mnemosyne, in the life of the Pueblo Indians living in the timeless universe. In this metaphysical universe created by the power of snakes (lightning-lightning), combinations such as power, passion and faith, which characterise the environment by getting rid of external concerns and the material world, are the first contexts, fictions or constructions of cultural codes that are renewed and transferred to the future.
It is also possible to analyse the Snake Dance as a visual analysis that contains the spirit of transformation created by Warburg and the clues of its era. Through the dances and objects of the natives, a mise-en-scene of an allegorical design has been created in which the boundaries of language and expression are destroyed with a reference to the order of the cultural world or a logic of association. In fact, the subject of a deep questioning between form and meaning is Warburg, who became the magician of the early modernist period. Therefore, the Pueblo Indians mean much more to Warburg’s life than the symbolic Snake Dance. And this situation also acquires a conceptual character in Warburg’s inventory as a cultural palimpsest and eternal repetition. The lightning that flashes with the clash of snakes turns into divine sparks and the illusion of the reality of the snake dance stands out among the masses of disorganised information, as if new codes of cultural correspondence are being written here. ♦
Gülay Yaşayanlar Copyright © 2025, All Rights Reserved
TOPICS
prof. gülay yaşayanlar Artist, art writer and curator. She has numerous publications on current issues, theoretical debates and prominent artist attitudes in the field of plastic arts. She lives and works in Izmir and London.
EXHIBITION & CATALOGUE
LIGHTENING SYMBOL AND SNAKE DANCE / 2022-23
Lightning Symbol and Snake Dance / Aby Warburg and Pueblo Art, Exhibition Poster (detail), Tasarım: Rocket & Wing
Blitzsymbol und Schlangentanz: Aby Warburg und die Pueblo-Kunst (Kulturgeschichte) Authors: Christine Chaves and Uwe Fleckner, Hatje Cantz Verlag, 400 pages, English, hardcover, March 2022.
Exhibition, Curators: Uwe Fleckner and Christine Chaves, 4 March 2022 – 8 Ocak 2023, MARKK / Museum am Rothenbaum Kulturen und Künste der Welt Rothenbaumchaussee 64 20148 Hamburg.
The Aby Warburg Collection is comprehensively presented with the Lightning Symbol and Snake Dance. In his famous 1923 lecture on the Snake Ritual, Warburg described in detail his 1895/96 journey through the American Southwest and his encounters with Pueblo societies there. The exhibition analyses the cultural significance of this travel and observation and critically examines the artistic position of Pueblo societies.
PREPARED BY GÜLAY YAŞAYANLAR & MÜMTAZ SAĞLAM
ON ABY WARBURG VE BILDERATLAS MNEMOSYNE
BOOK PUBLICATIONS
E.H. Gombrich, Aby Warburg: An Entellectual Biography / Phaidon Press Ltd. 456 pages, English, Hardback, August 1997.
Uwe Fleckner, Der Blitz und die Schlange: Aby Warburgs Amerikanische Reise (Kulturgeschichte), Hatje Cantz Verlag, 150 pages, English, Hardback, November 2023.
Hans C. Hönes, Tanged Paths: A life of Aby Warburg, Reaktion Books, 288 pages, English, Hardcover, May 2024.
Aby Warburg 150, Work, Legacy, Promise Edited by: David Freedberg and Claudia Wedepohl, 464 pages, De Gruyter Publishing, English, 1st Edition, April 2024.
Blitzsymbol und Schlangentanz: Aby Warburg und die Pueblo-Kunst (Kulturgeschichte) Authors: Christine Chaves and Uwe Fleckner, Hatje Cantz Verlag, 400 pages, English, hardcover, March 2022.
Lara Bonneau, Lire l’œuvre d’Aby Warburg à la lumière de ses Fragments sur l’expression, 264 pages, French Edition, softcover, Şubat 2022.
Aby Warburg Miroirs de faille – À Rome avec Giordano Bruno et Édouard Manet, 1928-29, Edited: Maurizio Ghelardi, L’écarquille Published, French Edition, softcover, 224 pages, June 2011.
Aby Warburg: Essay Florentins, Edited: Eveline Pinto and Sibylle Muller, Hazan Published, French Edition, softcover, 368 pages, April 2015.
Aby Warburg: Bilderatlas Mnemosyne / Das Original, Edited by Haus der Kulturen der Welt and The Warburg Institute; Roberto Ohrt, Axel Heil, Publisher: Bundeskunnsthalle Bonn, Hardcover 2020.
Christopher D. Johnson, Memory, Metaphor, and Aby Warburg’s Atlas of Images, Ithaca: Cornell University Library and Cornell University Press, 2012.
Aby Warburg, Atlas Mnemosyne, Translator: Joaquin Chamore Mielke, Akal Ediciones SA, 192 pages, Spanish, Hardcover, Marc 2010.
Aby Warburg: Bilderatlas Mnemosyne / The Original, Edited by Haus der Kulturen der Welt and The Warburg Institute; Roberto Ohrt, Axel Heil, Publisher: Hatje Cantz, 184 pg. English, Hardcover 2020.
Gerhard Richter: Atlas, Editor: Helmut Friedel, Verlag der Buchhandlung Walther König/D.A.P., Second edition, Following the first of 1997. 862 pages. 2011. Köln/New York.
Atlas: How to Carry the World on One’s Back?, Editor: Georges Didi Huberman, 421 pages, English, 2011.
Aby Warburg: Mnemosyne Bilderatlas ZKM 2016, Editor: Georges Didi Huberman, Kartoffelverlag, Universal-futur-Bitch Press, 2016
ABY WARBURG
saglamart; dinamik bir anlayış ile hareket eden, kültür-sanat ortamındaki olay ve olgulara, sanatçı tavırlarına, yapıtlara ve yayınlara odaklanan bağımsız bir yayın etkinliğidir. Tüm hakları saklıdır. All rights reserved. Görüntü ve yazılar izinsiz kullanılamaz. Images and texts cannot be used without permission.