Dan Flavin,
Untitled (for you Leo, in long respect and affection) 4, 1978,
Pink, green, blue and yellow fluorescent light,
121.92x121.92x5.08 cm., Acquired in 2010
Collection of the Modern Art Museum of Fort Worth, © 2012 Stephen Flavin / Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York

minimalism - 2

in pursuit of an aesthetic that creates spatial dynamism

GÜLAY YAŞAYANLAR & MÜMTAZ SAĞLAM

"

THE MINIMALIST DISPOSITION THAT CONSTRUCTS THE SURFACE THROUGH DECENTERED AND SIMULTANEOUS REPETITIONS OF MASS, OBJECT, AND IMAGE, THROUGH SEQUENTIAL ORDER AESTHETICS, THROUGH GRID OR MODULAR FORM, IS VALUED HERE FOR THE PURPOSE OF GENERATING AN INTELLECTUAL AND RATIONAL LOGIC OR RATIONALE. IN CERTAIN ARTISTS, THIS CONDITION, THE EFFORT TO DEVELOP AN IDEA OF ORDER THAT TRANSFORMS THROUGH FORMAL REPETITION INTO A COMPOSITION, APPEARS TO HAVE GRADUALLY BECOME AN INTERNAL NECESSITY, PUSHING AGAINST THE IMPLICATIONS OF MINIMALISM WITHIN A PROCESS OF PERSONAL STYLISTIC FORMATION.

Donald Judd, Judd, Installation view at Moma- Museum of Modern Art, New York. New York, March 1, 2020 - January 9, 2021.© MoMA

The continuing practices of artists who gave momentum to Early Minimalism appear, in subsequent years, to have almost lost their original purity owing to strategic affiliations. This sensibility, shaped by debates framed around the problematic of style formation and proposing a radical formal discipline, seems to have subsequently sought to embrace certain positions it had initially left unresolved or reacted against, abandoning the shared sensibility that had oriented points of consensus, and choosing instead to focus on the possibilities of developing an individual language. (1)

In this process, the work that Minimalist artists organized as a design phenomenon, and which rapidly became conceptual, is simultaneously a result attained through abstract comprehension and spatial sensibility. As is evident in Carl Andre‘s floor arrangements, this transformation, occurring at the intersection of material, object, and space, inevitably calls to be characterized as transcendent sculptures in which time and perception are made concrete. These sculptures, which activate holistic perception, swiftly aspire toward a spatial dynamism: a repetition-based, vibrational, and quietly harmonious aesthetic.

minimalism 1 andre yatay 16

Carl Andre: Sculptur as Place, 1958-2010, Exhibition View, May 5 - June 18, 2016, Hamburger Bahnhof - Nationalgalerie der Gegenwart, Berlin, Germany.

minimalism 1 serra yatay 23.jpg

Carl Andre, 48 Bar Rectangular Fugune on 4 Ancient Metals, Copper, steel, lead and zinc, in 48 parts, each 1x15x30 cm. installation view, Executed in 1988. (Private Collection, New York)

the interior spatial mediation of the elements constituting the sculpture

In this context, the linguistic development of Donald Judd’s visualization strategy is in fact related to the late modern transformation through which the image attains the dimension of object. This may be explained, in the first half of the 1960s, through a process of reduction in which the flat surface arrived at shaped metal surfaces, opening up the possibilities of movement and image. Formal articulation here, in Judd’s own terms, transforms into the specific object, or sculpture, while simultaneously being defined as critical abstraction, inquiry, and aesthetic play. (2) It is therefore possible to read Judd’s wall-mounted rows of boxes within this framework as a gesture of installation and arrangement based on the repetition of similar forms at regular intervals, a gesture that already holds a privileged status as a straightforward effort to foreclose the possibilities of meaning.

Donald Judd’s wall sculpture composed of stacked boxes is, in essence, an endeavor that completes the sculpture through dimensioning engaged with void, within a minimal configuration that adheres to conditions of order, discipline, and balance. Accordingly, the question of whether the void surrounding the interval-based arrangement of objects produces a cultural spatial effect, or whether it adds a psychological dimension to the sculpture, remains persistently contested. For within the interior spatial mediation of the elements constituting the sculpture, material neutrality appears to have been surpassed, yielding instead, as Robert Morris too perceived, to a visuality grounded in repetition and rhythm. It is as though Minimalism conceals here, within this register, a portion of the representation it has cancelled through abstraction. In this way, through repetition, the semiotic logic of representation is overturned. Similarly, Dan Flavin, placing his fluorescent tubes in a kind of strange solitude against a simple background, adopts an approach that resists meaning through minimal compositional arrangement. Here, while the functional value, use-value, or meaning carried by the luminous form as object is bypassed, one is left alone with the minimal aesthetic derived from the logic of stacking and formal discipline. It is thus evident that the unmediated dimension of the repeatedly presented object, in its abstract, singular, and distanced solitude, lends itself to a tendency toward conceptualization as a structural and discursive choice.

minimalism 1 yatay 9

Robert Morris, Untitled (Three L-Beams),1969, Refabrication of 1965 original, Plywood, later versions made in fiberglass and stainless stell, 244.3x244.3x61 cm., © Robert Morris.

the need for a psychic and cultural implication

It is precisely at this juncture that Sol LeWitt distinguishes himself: arriving at imagistic totality through geometric formal repetition and density, yet diversifying this approach through painterly color fields extended onto wall surfaces. LeWitt layers the question of rhythm and repetition, through alternative dimensioning experiments that generate pattern, with a far more psychic and cultural implication, preferring to produce site-specific, varied, and proliferating solutions through the direct relationships he establishes within space. The structural implication’s priority, grounded in the rejection of narrative connections or possibilities, and the object-form’s state of isolation at the threshold of the abstract and the simple, leaves nothing but a reference to its own solitude.

The Minimalist disposition that constructs the surface through decentered and simultaneous repetitions of mass, object, and image, through sequential order aesthetics, through grid or modular form, is valued here for the purpose of generating an intellectual and rational logic or rationale. In certain artists, this condition, the effort to develop an idea of order that transforms through formal repetition into a composition, appears to have gradually become an internal necessity, pushing against the implications of Minimalism within a process of personal stylistic formation. Sol LeWitt’s increasingly color-enriched use of form and motif serves as an effective illustration of this reality. (3) The artist continued in subsequent years on a journey in search of a new aesthetic sensibility, one taking the shape of modular form-pattern configurations, accompanied by the rhythmic and compelling visual effects produced by repetition-based order.

Minimalist artists, in production practices that move between sculpture and installation, doubtless employ the object in accordance with a principle of order, harmony, or tension, much as Donald Judd’s practice exemplifies. (4) That is to say, a great many works are concerned with the meaning, simplicity, and directness of an existing order. The similarity, companionship, and multiplicity of forms is also of primary importance in this context. To return to the beginning: the general harmony achieved through repetition functions as a shared goal. This condition, related to the overall visual order, may be explained in the cases of Judd and Morris through the relationship that similar and sequential forms belonging to an interior experiential register establish with the exterior within this field of experience. Purely in this respect, the sculptural arrangements of Judd and Morris contain the psychological intimacy of a meaning confined within the massive presence of forms. What is remarkable is that within this environment, which appears sufficiently unemotional and sterile, this psychological weight nonetheless confronts us as a possibility or intensity of minimal coherence and meaning. Yet the very idea of psychological intimacy, fragmented by the multiplicity of the object and drained of its force by repetition, would be expected to reject this manner of being understood through experience. In any case, the geometric form and repetition tendency of Judd and Morris, or of Serra and LeWitt, as a practice of creating a static and synthetic internal order, already distances sculpture thoroughly from Minimalism at this point.

notes

1 Hal Foster, Gerçeğin Geri Dönüşü / The Return of the Real, Translation: Esin Hoşsucu, Turkish, Ayrıntı Publishing, May 2009, İstanbul. pg. 91.

2  Hal Foster, Ibid, pg. 74.

3 See. Rosalind Krause, Modern Heykelin Dehlizleri / Passages in Modern Sculpture, Translation: Sibel Erduran, Everest Publishing, October 2021, İstanbul.

4 See. Rosalind Krause, Ibid, pg. 302.

Gülay Yaşayanlar & Mümtaz Sağlam  Copyright © March 2026, All rights reserved.

A FIle on MInImalIsm at Saglamart 

A COLLECTION EXHIBITION

MINIMALIST ARTISTS 

 MInImalIst ArtIsts at Saglamart 

MINIMALIZM / 5 BOOKS

Minimalizm 1 Book 2

Daniel Marzona, Minimal Art, Tashen Deutschland, 25. Edition, German, Hardcover, 200 pages, 2009.

Minimalizm 1 Book 7

James Meyer, Minimalism / Art and Polemics in the Sixties, Yale University Press, English, Paperback, 340 pages, August 2004.

Minimalizm 1 Book 8

Minimalism, Edited by James Meyer, Phaidon Press, English, Soft Cover, 200 pages, June 2010.

Minimalizm 1 Book 9

Minimalism, Edited by James Meyer, Phaidon Press, English, Paperback, 304 pages, March 2005.

David Batchelor, Minimalizm, Translation: Tüles Üresin, Hayalperest Publication, Turkish, Paperback, 96 pages, İstanbul 2025.

SOL LEWITT: Conceptual Movement IN THE VISUAL AREA

İZMİR - LONDON

saglamart; dinamik bir anlayış ile hareket eden, kültür-sanat ortamındaki olay ve olgulara, sanatçı tavırlarına, yapıtlara ve yayınlara odaklanan bağımsız bir yayın etkinliğidir. Tüm hakları saklıdır. Görüntü ve yazılar izinsiz kullanılamaz. / saglamart is an independent publishing initiative driven by a dynamic vision, focusing on events and developments in the cultural-artistic landscape, artist perspectives, works, and publications. All rights reserved. Images and texts cannot be used without permission.

Copyright ©
Can Sağlam - Gülay Yaşayanlar Mümtaz Sağlam, 2025.